Khilafat movement, nehru report and jinnahs 14 point. Quaidiazam demanded rd representation in central government for muslims but nehru report gave 14th representation to muslims in central government. Though the process of drafting a constitutional framework was begun enthusiastically and unitedly by political leaders, communal differences crept in and the nehru report got. Separate electorates were refused and the reservation of seats for the muslims of bengal and punjab was rejected. The nehru report of 10 august 1928 was a memorandum to appeal for a new dominion status and a federal setup of government for the constitution of india. In this report, not a single demand of the muslims was upheld. Since nehru report was the last word from hindus therefore mr. Quaidiazam mohammad ali jinnah and fundamental rights. Jinnah served as the leader of the allindia muslim league from 19 until pakistans creation on 14 august 1947, and then as pakistans first governorgeneral until his death. A comparison of the nehru report 1928 with jinnahs fourteen points shows a political gap between the muslims and the hindus in india. Jinnah s fourteen points study material pdf download. The fourteen points of quaideazam muhammad ali jinnah. The report was given in a meeting of the council of the all india muslim league on march 28, 1929. Fourteen points of jinnah translation in englishurdu dictionary.
Fourteen points of jinnah translation englishurdu dictionary. Jinnah felt that muslims had sacrificed too much in order to reach a compromise the issue of communal representation. How can i learn the 14 points of quaideazam in short. Jul 06, 2016 jinnah demands 3 amendment to nehru report. The dynamic personality of quaidiazam mohammad ali jinnah, the founder of pakistan, was a combination of the characteristics of the eminent leaders of the world. Cambridge international examinations cambridge ordinary level. As for example, they had allowed congress to go back on concessions granted by the lucknow pact of 1916. Quaidiazam mohammad ali jinnah and fundamental rights syed sharifuddin pirzada. I want to learn the 14 points of quaideazam in short. That committee prepared a report which is known as nehru report. This was the first major attempt by indians to draft a constitution for themselves. In 1928, an all parties conference was convened to solve the constitutional problems of india.
The fourteen points of jinnah were proposed by muhammad ali jinnah as a constitutional reform plan to safeguard the political rights of muslims in a selfgoverning india. Quaideazam muhammad ali jinnah was born on 25 december 1876 in karachi. Found 0 sentences matching phrase fourteen points of jinnah. Consequently, he framed the fourteen points providing protection to the muslims. Jinnah s 14 points spectrum series by anuj garg part 14 duration. He tried to amend the nehru report or get more rights in it but failed and therefore gave his 14 points. Jinnah tried to make amendments in the nehru report but could not succeed.
Nehru report was totally unacceptable to almost every muslim group in the subcontinent. Critical analysis of 14 points and nehru report css forums. Since these demands of jinnah were not met, he gave the fourteen points in march 1929, which served. Jan 21, 2015 nehru report and jinnahs fourteen points 1. They passed a resolution according to which no scheme for the future constitution was tolerable to the muslim league, if it did not include the demands presented in the fourteen points. Fourteen points of quaideazamoutline 1 fourteen points of quaideazam 2 introduction 3 jinnah s fourteen points 1929 1. Spectrum for modern history chapter 5 part 11 14 points of. The fourteen points of jinnah were proposed by muhammad ali jinnah as a constitutional. View notes fourteen points of quaideazam from olevel pakistan h at beaconhouse school system.
The form of the future constitution should be federal, with the residuary power vested in the provinces. Jinnah 14 points introduction in 1928,an all parties conference was convened to solve the constitutional problems of india. Muhammad ali jinnah left for england in may 1928 and returned after six months. The essence of jinnah s fourteen points was to strike a profitable bargain with the congress or to reject the nehru report. Jinnahs fourteen points on march 28 1929, a meeting of the council of the all india muslim league was held. Explain jinnahs 14 points in detail english summary. Separate electorates were refused and the reservation of seats for the muslims of bengal and. Jinnah 1929 a positive aspect of nehru report was that it resulted. Comparison between jinnahs 14 points with nehru report. Nehru report and jinnahs fourteen points free download as powerpoint presentation. In order to counter the proposals made in the nehru report, jinnah presented his proposal in the form of fourteen points, insisting. The report was submitted at the lucknow session of the allparty conference on august 28, 1928. Background a positive aspect of nehru report was that it resulted in the unity of divided muslim groups.
Jinnah 1929 a positive aspect of nehru report was that it resulted in the unity of divided muslim groups. Jinnah produced his fourteen points in response to the nehru report in 1929. In march 1929, the muslim league session was held at delhi. In a meeting of the council of all india muslim league on march 28, 1929, members of both the shafi league and jinnah league participated. Jinnah was authorized to draft in concise term the basis of any future constitution that was to be devised for india jinnah s aim was to get rights for muslims. Nehru report and jinnahs fourteen points slideshare. Among them mohammed ali jinnah was a prominent figure. This video is highly rated by upsc students and has been viewed 725 times. Fourteen points canopied the muslims of the subcontinent from the injustices and anticipated atrocities of the hindus in the years to come. Reaction to nehru report was the famous fourteen points of jinnah. Mohammed ali jinnah pakistani governorgeneral britannica. Representation of minoritiesthe nehru report and fourteen points of ma jinnah 1929. Their demands were elaborated by jinnah in the form of an amendment at the representative convention of calcutta 22 dec. Nehru report and jinnahs fourteen points muhammad ali.
It was prepared by a committee of the all parties conference caried by motilal nehru with his son jawaharlal nehru acting as a secretary. Demand for dominion status and civil disobedience movement for poornaswaraj. Pakistan studies muhammad ali jinnah two nation theory. Quaidiazam termed the nehru report as a hindu document, but considered simply rejecting the report as insufficient. It is true that demand of separation of sind from bombay was considered in the nehru report as jinnah mentioned in his 14 points but the condition of selfeconomy was also put forward. Cambridge international examinations cambridge ordinary level 3290229812. Muhammad ali jinnah presented the fourteen points in response to the nehru report. Simon commission, the nehru report, the fourteen points, round table conferences and. The draft constitution prepared by the committee was called the nehru committee report or nehru report. Tried to amend the nehru report resulted in a parting of the ways response to nehru report, deadlock since muslims no nehru report, congress no 14 points. Muhammad ali jinnah fourteen points of jinnah genius.
The main difference and pivot of the whole question is that the congress while claiming for itself the right to represt the whole of india denies the muslim league the right to. A comparison of the nehru report with the quaideazams fourteen points shows that the political gap between the muslims and the hindus had really widened. Sep 27, 2010 comparison between jinnahs 14 points with nehru report jinnahs 14 points. Jan 29, 2015 however, the government of india act 1935 owes much to the simon commission report and little, if anything to the nehru report. These fourteen points clearly reflected the demands, sentiments and aspirations of the. Jinnah wanted seperate muslim electorates in the indian govt. After his arrival, he left karachi and settled in bombay. The given fourteen points were accepted by the council of the all india muslim league. Muhammad ali jinnah biography facts 14 points in urdu. The whole text of the nehru report 1928 can be downloaded from this website by clicking on the link below. Many muslims were not enthusiastic about the nehru report. How can i learn the 14 points of quaideazam in short terms.
Mohammed ali jinnah, indian muslim politician, who was the founder and first governorgeneral 194748 of pakistan. Spectrum for modern history chapter 5 part 11 14 points. Cmp14 league rejected plan, called direct action, julyaugust 1946. Some registers their date of birth is 20 october 1875. It also proposed for the joint electorates with reservation of seats for minorities in the legislatures. Muhammad ali jinnah got his early education from sindh madrassatulislam.
What is the difference between jinnahs 14 point and nehru. Jinnah knew british were going to introduce reforms, so informed them of muslim demands. May 01, 2020 simon commission,nehru report, jinnahs 14 points,delhi manifesto upsc video edurev is made by best teachers of upsc. At the allparty conference held in calcutta in 1928 to discuss the report, jinnah made three amendments to the report. Aug 20, 2014 in 14 points of muhammad ali jinnah weightage for minorities was demanded but nehru in his report did not compromise with our quaid. Get an answer for how can i learn the 14 points of quaideazam in short terms. At the same time jinnah after consulting the muslim leaders formulated the fourteen points for safeguarding the rights and interests of the muslims in any future constitution of the country. Simon commission,nehru report,jinnahs 14 points,delhi. Muhammad ali jinnah as a constitutional reform plan to safeguard the political rights of muslims in a selfgoverning india. In this page we give you information, life history and. May 01, 2014 fourteen points of quaideazam introduction in 1928,an all parties conference was convened to solve the constitutional problems of india. Jinnah thereafter drew up a list of demands, the socalled fourteen points, which represented the minimum demands of the muslims. Nehru report 1928 civil disobedient movement salt satyagraha. On december 1928, during all parties meeting jinnah proposed some amendments on the nehrus report.
This is produced for each series of examinations and is freely available to download at uk after. Cmp4 jinnah and ml responses to the cmp 22 may and june 6 1946. Jinnahs fourteen points 1929 study material exams daily. Jinnah was the eldest of seven children of jinnahbhai poonja, a prosperous merchant, and his wife, mithibai. The nehru report and fourteen points of ma jinnah it was in this meeting that.
In the all parties meeting at calcutta in december 1928, jinnah moved certain amendments to the nehru report. Apr 20, 2018 spectrum for modern history chapter 5 part 11 14 points of jinnah in hindi. Mar 07, 2020 jinnah convened an all india conference of the muslims where he drew up a list of fourteen points as muslim league demand jinnah s 14 points these points covered all of the interests of the muslims at a heated time and in this jinnah stated that it was the parting of ways and that he did not want and would not have anything to do with the. A comparison of the nehru report 1928 with jinnahs fourteen points had a political gap between the muslims and the hindus in india. Khilafat movement, nehru report and jinnah s 14 point ehsan irshad. Since these demands of jinnah were not met, he gave the fourteen points in march 1929, which served as the basis of all future agenda of the league. On the other end quaideazam was believe on the provincial autonomy. What is the difference between jinnahs 14 point and nehrus report.
1173 171 842 1453 1372 1342 1242 639 1087 174 1034 328 867 714 1516 403 56 446 336 34 364 236 1113 280 329 568 621 432 1474 978 324 744 937 1011 162 1406 398 514 1077 905 978 807